{"anchorId": "ca_HDJJgXgG", "prerequisiteId": "ca_9MTwuMQj", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先听辨音乐中的情绪和情感变化，就无法根据情感表达选用合适的音乐", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "他会在播放列表里随机点一首，然后问老师‘这首行不行’，而不是根据情境自己选。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "1c95b65c691724c7"}
{"anchorId": "ca_CLymqGRK", "prerequisiteId": "ca_SxrKsY92", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能分析音乐表现要素与体裁、形式的关系，就无法综合分析情绪变化的原因", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "指着钢琴声说'因为用了小提琴所以悲伤'，把乐器和情绪搞混了。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "f58914f3ce658c0c", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_3cFkErs7", "prerequisiteId": "ca_NBdvkmXC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "区分类别和形式是区分歌曲类别和演唱形式的核心前置能力", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 9，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "听到合唱时，他无法区分是混声合唱还是童声合唱，只能笼统地说是‘很多人一起唱’。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "b4dfe4d4a0f8bbaf", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_SibDLmx3", "prerequisiteId": "ca_NBdvkmXC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会区分音乐体裁和表现形式，就无法区分地区和民族音乐的风格", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 9，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "在播放一首蒙古族长调时，该生无法说出体裁，但在区分地区风格时，他只能简单重复‘这个是蒙古的’、‘这个是江南的’，无法进一步描述音乐特点或比较不同。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "7ac36fc24ca234d6"}
{"anchorId": "ca_SibDLmx3", "prerequisiteId": "ca_CLymqGRK", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会从音乐要素分析情绪变化，就无法理解地区和民族音乐的风格差异", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "6a73ea1705b8902f"}
{"anchorId": "ca_4Rj3vE85", "prerequisiteId": "ca_NBdvkmXC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能区分音乐的体裁、类别和表现形式，就无法说出它们在表现形式上的区别和联系", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 9，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他只能盯着书本重复念出“音乐是听觉的，舞蹈是视觉的”这类句子，但无法举出具体例子，比如《天鹅湖》中音乐如何推动舞蹈情节，只会反复说“就是不一样”", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "fbf5ba49805202e3", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_4Rj3vE85", "prerequisiteId": "ca_SxrKsY92", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能分析音乐表现要素与体裁、形式的关系，就无法系统地说出它们在表现形式上的区别和联系", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他无法区分音乐体裁，因此在比较音乐与舞蹈时，会把舞蹈的节奏特点错误地归为音乐体裁，或无法指出音乐在戏剧中作为背景音效的具体作用。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "dd4d87d82463d25e", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_UNbvxHKe", "prerequisiteId": "ca_CLymqGRK", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会从音乐要素分析音乐情绪变化，就无法根据情感表达选用合适音乐", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "翻遍曲库后凭感觉挑了几首伤感歌，被问为什么选这首时只会说“因为歌词难过”或“旋律慢”，说不出调性或节奏变化如何支撑情绪层次", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "d53197ae133ff26c", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_n2A3hBPG", "prerequisiteId": "ca_CLymqGRK", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析音乐要素对情绪的影响，就无法运用知识和听觉经验进行音乐实践。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他听山歌时，只会说“好听”或“不好听”，但说不出为什么这段旋律起伏大、节奏自由，而另一段旋律平稳、节奏规整。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "c0abf613cdc50e58", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_n2A3hBPG", "prerequisiteId": "ca_SxrKsY92", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析音乐要素与体裁形式的关系，就无法在运用知识时进行综合阐述。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 11，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "面对一首劳动号子，他会皱眉说‘这听起来像信天游’，把两者混为一谈，因为不知道怎么从节奏和功能上区分。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "8effdb3937d1ddfe", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_MQCrMQfj", "prerequisiteId": "ca_CLymqGRK", "strength": "soft", "reason": "需要先会分析音乐要素与情绪的关系，才能作出判断和简单描述。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "363420d55a875c73"}
{"anchorId": "ca_MQCrMQfj", "prerequisiteId": "ca_NBdvkmXC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "需要先会区分体裁和表现形式，才能对音乐进行判断和描述。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他会失败在判断体裁这一步，比如听到一首民歌，他会说这是交响乐，因为他分不清旋律特征和乐器音色。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "4433ffe4ea9efd15", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_tYiB4tEC", "prerequisiteId": "ca_CLymqGRK", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析音乐要素对情绪的影响，就无法分析姊妹艺术中音乐的特点", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他分析舞蹈配乐时，只会说“这段音乐很悲伤”，但无法指出是哪个乐器或节奏变化导致了这种感觉。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "30fc9abc4589e40f", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_P75d86DG", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Y65MiK6b", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能运用乐器编创和表现音乐，就无法在演奏中融入个性化的理解和创意。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 19，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他看着乐谱，手指按顺序按下音符，但速度和力度始终一样，弹完就停下，没有任何强弱或快慢的变化。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "c7a1e538ccbd4e9f"}
{"anchorId": "ca_HueWm8JV", "prerequisiteId": "ca_ViFhCEpr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "即兴创作需基于对节奏或旋律编创中重复与变化的掌握", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 30，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "他只能反复弹奏同一个和弦，无法根据画面变化调整节奏或音高。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "9533d1fc5e9c6bc8"}
{"anchorId": "ca_KZnXdrmV", "prerequisiteId": "ca_aeXFwdhF", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会简单音乐编创软件或技术，就无法完成数字形式的音乐创作", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 32，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生面对空白乐谱纸，手握笔却迟迟无法下笔，反复涂改纸面，最终交出的纸上只有几个零散的音符，无法连成完整的乐句。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "b46e19c610fd45be", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_KZnXdrmV", "prerequisiteId": "ca_JQ2P7v3R", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能识读简单乐谱，就无法将音乐构思转化为准确的乐谱记录", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 20，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生无法根据哼唱或想象的旋律在纸上写出对应的音符，只能用画圈或涂鸦代替记谱。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "05e996c71903a571", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_aeXFwdhF", "prerequisiteId": "ca_JQ2P7v3R", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能识读简单乐谱，就无法运用软件进行音乐编创或编辑。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 20，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他会在软件里找不到对应音符的按钮，只能用鼠标在钢琴卷帘窗里随机点击，听声音猜位置，导致编出的旋律音高和节奏完全混乱。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "caf7a0e5cc604e6d", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ZybYqDTi", "prerequisiteId": "ca_tYiB4tEC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析舞蹈戏剧中音乐的特点，就无法感知其审美特征与风格", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 14，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "看舞蹈片段时，只会说‘好看’或‘不好看’，无法指出具体是舞蹈动作的流畅性、服装色彩的协调性还是灯光氛围的营造带来的审美感受。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "7b190a2adfc41b57", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_KzbhtJPw", "prerequisiteId": "ca_CLymqGRK", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析音乐要素如何影响情绪，就无法评价音乐在其他艺术中的表现作用", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他分析舞蹈配乐时，只会说'这段音乐很悲伤'，但说不出是因为弦乐用了小调和慢速，导致舞蹈动作也显得沉重。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "7f73d57ad83826fb", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_KzbhtJPw", "prerequisiteId": "ca_tYiB4tEC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会对姊妹艺术中音乐特点与作用作出分析，就无法进一步评价其表现作用", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 14，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "在分析电影配乐时，只能复述剧情，说不出音乐如何烘托了角色的情绪或场景的氛围。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "1befffc4cdada76d", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_AmiAFxFQ", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Rg2mNCdA", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能提出构想并尝试多种表现形式，就无法主动探寻解决方案并持之以恒完成创作。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "画了几笔就说不会画了，把纸揉成一团扔掉，拒绝再动笔。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "002c9fd85a1254aa"}
{"anchorId": "ca_kVWrSGi6", "prerequisiteId": "ca_JuwMpqAG", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先学会收拾整理工具和材料，就无法保障设计美化活动的有序进行。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 18，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "30b203845c6cd609"}
{"anchorId": "ca_emrgtzaY", "prerequisiteId": "ca_ZybYqDTi", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先感知舞蹈的审美特征与风格，就难以体会其文化内涵。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 35，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "模仿时手脚僵硬，无法连贯完成动作，且无法说出该舞蹈的风格或文化背景。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "c357dae90d4a3316", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_q4XM68Nq", "prerequisiteId": "ca_ZybYqDTi", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先感知和了解舞蹈等艺术的审美特征，就无法比较其表现形式的异同。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 35，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "老师让他指出两个视频里舞者手臂动作的相同和不同，他看着屏幕，一会儿说这个是古典舞那个是现代舞，一会儿又说这段表达悲伤那段表达喜悦，就是说不出两人手臂一个是直的一个是弯的这种具体形态差别。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "675ad73d8b819261", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_BJaacPhS", "prerequisiteId": "ca_JQ2P7v3R", "strength": "soft", "reason": "识读乐谱是理解和配合音乐、声部等舞台要素的基础。", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 20，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "排练时，他无法根据乐谱提示的节奏和速度进入，总是比其他演员慢半拍或快半拍，导致动作和音乐对不上。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "f05add0d17079ac8"}
{"anchorId": "ca_wdxeb4JG", "prerequisiteId": "ca_tYiB4tEC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析音乐在影视中的特点，就无法对影视作品进行辨析和评价", "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 14，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "在分析影视作品音乐时，学生无法说出音乐如何配合画面推动情节或渲染情绪，只能描述‘音乐在响’，或复述剧情而完全忽略声音部分。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "41e3c563f193f6e8", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_HNcVRaNT", "prerequisiteId": "ca_9MTwuMQj", "strength": "soft", "reason": "听辨音乐要素变化是理解记号作用的基础，有助于在演唱中调整表现。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "看到谱面上的渐强记号，他没有逐渐加大音量，而是从头到尾用同样大小的声音唱完。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "146d0e8d7e35ef06", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_y8igaEis", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Mrc7LZYx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会演奏简单节奏型并伴奏，就无法用乐器声音材料进行模仿或表现", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 18，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G3"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生会模仿单一声音如狗叫，但无法将三个连续声音如狗叫、猫叫、鸡叫组合成一段有顺序的模仿序列", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "c7e11291beef424c", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_E7X5tLJn", "prerequisiteId": "ca_EPeydzSh", "strength": "soft", "reason": "目标能力要求设计日常物品，需先掌握基本的设计制作能力。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 31，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "只会用画图工具涂色，不会用图形工具对齐图形，也不会把图形组合成整体。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "0912447550ba3ff5", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_3cFkErs7", "prerequisiteId": "ca_SxrKsY92", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会区分音乐的体裁、类别和表现形式，就无法区分歌曲的不同类别和演唱形式", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "18443bda781ea494"}
{"anchorId": "ca_SibDLmx3", "prerequisiteId": "ca_n2A3hBPG", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会区分中国民歌的基本体裁，就无法区分我国有代表性的地区和民族音乐风格", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 11，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "播放《茉莉花》时，他无法判断这是江南小调还是西北信天游，只能凭感觉乱猜，把风格相似的歌曲归为一类。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "e89a68f771549c03", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_SibDLmx3", "prerequisiteId": "ca_MQCrMQfj", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会对世界民族民间音乐的风格类型作出判断，就无法区分我国有代表性的地区和民族音乐风格", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 12，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "听一段苗族飞歌和蒙古长调，他会说‘都是山歌’或‘都有很多装饰音’，说不出一个高亢婉转、一个悠长辽阔的区别", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "6b2cb38793ea1009", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_4Rj3vE85", "prerequisiteId": "ca_tYiB4tEC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析音乐在舞蹈、戏剧、影视中的特点，就无法比较它们表现形式的区别和联系", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 13，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "6c49c32133e998c9"}
{"anchorId": "ca_4Rj3vE85", "prerequisiteId": "ca_ZybYqDTi", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会说出舞蹈或戏剧片段的审美特征与风格特点，就无法比较不同艺术形式的表现差异", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 35，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "d982ae86f80d131d"}
{"anchorId": "ca_MQCrMQfj", "prerequisiteId": "ca_SxrKsY92", "strength": "soft", "reason": "能区分所听音乐的体裁、类别和表现形式，并运用所学知识分析其特点和表现作用，为判断和描述音乐作品提供了必要的分析框架。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 11，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他无法区分体裁，只能指着乐谱说‘这是音乐’，或把所有作品都归为‘好听的歌’。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "dba1f2947cec5dcc", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_tYiB4tEC", "prerequisiteId": "ca_NBdvkmXC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能说出乐曲体裁形式并分析特点，就无法评价其在姊妹艺术中的表现作用", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "看舞蹈视频时，他说不出这段音乐是哪种类别，也分析不出音乐如何配合舞蹈动作，只是说‘音乐挺快的’。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "af5619123d89289f", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_tYiB4tEC", "prerequisiteId": "ca_SxrKsY92", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能区分体裁形式并分析特点，就无法在姊妹艺术中进行分析评价", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 11，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "他在分析舞蹈音乐特点时，会反复盯着舞者动作却说不出音乐节奏如何配合，或者直接抄写教材上的‘欢快’‘抒情’等词，但无法解释这些词与具体音符、乐器的关系。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "5702d8770c83b6be"}
{"anchorId": "ca_aeXFwdhF", "prerequisiteId": "ca_ViFhCEpr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会独立或合作编创节奏或旋律，就无法进行软件音乐编创。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 31，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他会在软件里反复拖拽同一个音符，无法组合出有变化的节奏型，只会复制粘贴相同的片段。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "de7c67c3b21ca3e8", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_9h3jXhQd", "prerequisiteId": "ca_P75d86DG", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能在演奏中融入个性化理解和创意，就无法在表演中展现音乐风格和特点。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 24，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "38beb37ce871cfc0"}
{"anchorId": "ca_AB39EVss", "prerequisiteId": "ca_CLymqGRK", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析音乐情绪变化原因，就无法用身体语言准确表达情感", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他只是跟着音乐随意晃动身体，没有在旋律起伏时改变动作幅度，也没有在节奏变化时调整动作速度。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "2007307d44f24285"}
{"anchorId": "ca_q4XM68Nq", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4Rj3vE85", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解音乐与舞蹈在表现形式上的区别和联系，就无法识别不同舞蹈形式的异同", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 7，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "让学生比较古典舞和芭蕾舞，学生可能只说'都是跳舞'，无法指出'古典舞讲究身韵、芭蕾讲究开绷直立'等具体表现形式差异", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "01d8a572bf7c4bb7", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_6kuQkLDH", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4oJdnTHW", "strength": "soft", "reason": "对称是理解形式原理的基础，是学习造型元素中形状和空间关系的前提。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 18，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "note": "端点断言已按课标原文动词修正，先修判断需重看", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生看着印好的画，只说出‘有红有蓝’和‘这是方块’，但无法解释这些颜色和形状在纸上如何组合成不同区域，说不出‘色彩形状的组合形成了画面空间’。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "ea62a532d62471a2", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_TIMBScHh", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4mBPhXJr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "中国传统绘画技法是传统绘画的基础知识，不掌握则无法理解其文化地位", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 34，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "d3bc7b2700cec35d"}
{"anchorId": "ca_6v98UFFD", "prerequisiteId": "ca_wxy93nLa", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道中国传统工艺是文化瑰宝，就难以理解世界各国美术作品的文化载体属性", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 20，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "594f045198df236b"}
{"anchorId": "ca_b3k9s1Df", "prerequisiteId": "ca_wxy93nLa", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道传统工艺是文化瑰宝，就难以认识其创作原则的重要性", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 20，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "在讨论传统工艺的创新时，他无法举例说明传统工艺本身的‘瑰宝’之处，比如无法说出景泰蓝、云锦等具体工艺的名称或特点，导致论证空洞。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "1725b8edcd7acb2e", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_w4O2D1Xr", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4mBPhXJr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "三远法属于中国传统绘画技法，不先知道其历史渊源就无法准确掌握。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 34，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "67ff422710ca8f6f"}
{"anchorId": "ca_BVd9yLg4", "prerequisiteId": "ca_o5ghwPHL", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解实用与美观结合的设计原则，就无法理解形式、功能与社会责任的统一", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 35，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生可能直接说'设计就是要好看又好用'，但无法展开'形式'和'功能'的具体含义，更说不出'社会责任'，只会反复重复'实用美观'或'好用好看'。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "c7d5af35462153c5", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_o5ghwPHL", "prerequisiteId": "ca_e5u7YFZu", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道日常用品经过设计，就无法理解设计中实用与美观结合的原则", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 13，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G3"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "当被问及设计原则时，他可能会困惑地反问：‘设计是什么？’或者直接回答：‘我不知道，我只知道怎么用东西。’", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "62ce5fcb08f292d0", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_6kuQkLDH", "prerequisiteId": "ca_aznbaEsx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "平行透视是理解空间变化规律的基础，是学习造型元素中空间概念的前提。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 11，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "676b33ddff3910d8"}
{"anchorId": "ca_aflpJ0Do", "prerequisiteId": "ca_o5ghwPHL", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解设计原则就无法理解更高层次的环境设计原则", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 13，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "d3987a67e3cf9d50"}
{"anchorId": "ca_6v98UFFD", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4mBPhXJr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解中国传统绘画技法的探索总结，就难以理解不同文化美术作品的差异性", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 12，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "1be5971c7ad13f45"}
{"anchorId": "ca_b3k9s1Df", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4mBPhXJr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解传统绘画技法的探索总结过程，就无法理解继承与创新的关系", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 12，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "bff2deff06bcf098"}
{"anchorId": "ca_E7X5tLJn", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6kuQkLDH", "strength": "soft", "reason": "设计日常物品与居室环境需理解形状、色彩、空间等基本造型元素。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 18，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "在拖拽图形工具时，学生无法有意识地选择圆形或矩形来组合物品轮廓，而是随意点击素材库里所有颜色鲜艳的形状，堆砌出杂乱无章的图案。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "ea75a7e44a0232d7"}
{"anchorId": "ca_E7X5tLJn", "prerequisiteId": "ca_aflpJ0Do", "strength": "soft", "reason": "设计居室环境需理解人与自然和谐共生等环境设计原则。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 19，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "6b561d6278e70b36"}
{"anchorId": "ca_3auPHa3i", "prerequisiteId": "ca_9MTwuMQj", "strength": "soft", "reason": "听赏与评述需要先具备听辨音乐情绪和情感变化的能力", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 14，模型提议未复核"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G3"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他无法举例说明听赏与评述如何帮助他理解音乐，只能重复课本上的定义，比如背诵“听赏是重要的学习任务”，但说不出具体例子。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "b77391dfc75bf677"}
{"anchorId": "ca_3auPHa3i", "prerequisiteId": "ca_i4vVPJMs", "strength": "soft", "reason": "聆听音乐并描述特征是进行音乐评述的基础能力", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 28，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "69b81e839879a968"}
{"anchorId": "ca_nutkmCrm", "prerequisiteId": "ca_ugSgRPcr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "必须先掌握广义音乐作品可以是节奏或旋律，才能进一步理解可以是动作或舞蹈", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 2，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生低头沉默，无法说出任何答案。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "25962117f5a87d98", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_X3pI2fSV", "prerequisiteId": "ca_ugSgRPcr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解音乐作品可以是节奏或旋律，就无法扩展到戏剧片段等更广义形式", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 2，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生会卡在第一步，无法说出广义音乐作品可以是节奏或旋律，因此无法类比到戏剧片段，只能沉默或摇头。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "9120b70fabf602c1", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_X3pI2fSV", "prerequisiteId": "ca_nutkmCrm", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解音乐作品可以是动作或舞蹈，就无法类比理解戏剧片段作为音乐作品", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 3，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "44d0a3469e12d31c"}
{"anchorId": "ca_6v98UFFD", "prerequisiteId": "ca_JNUfKbit", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解美术是认识与表现世界的方式，就无法理解其作为文化载体的作用", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 6，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "a6f2afa242a984a2"}
{"anchorId": "ca_JNUfKbit", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6kuQkLDH", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先掌握形状、色彩、空间等造型元素，就无法理解美术作为认识与表现方式的基础。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 3，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "113e8a6bbee8b470"}
{"anchorId": "ca_6tiC4rHQ", "prerequisiteId": "ca_X3pI2fSV", "strength": "soft", "reason": "戏剧游戏属于戏剧范畴，需先知道戏剧片段是广义音乐作品之一", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 4，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "2ecb54c2b87991d8"}
{"anchorId": "ca_GcHZA1D2", "prerequisiteId": "ca_X3pI2fSV", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道戏剧片段是广义音乐作品，就无法理解演出舞台剧目属于艺术学习任务。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 4，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他可能把“演出舞台剧目”误解为只有纯音乐作品才能表演，从而在列举剧目时，排除了《雷雨》《哈姆雷特》这类非音乐性戏剧片段，导致答案不完整。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "7b50f91803fa7d97"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ViFhCEpr", "prerequisiteId": "ca_kMJGYbpW", "type": "component", "strength": "hard", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他只能把所有节奏都敲成一样，无法变奏，或者乱加花，和别人合不上。", "reason": "「按要求独立或与他人合作编创有重复和变化的」是母条「按要求独立或与他人合作编创、表现有重复和」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "e8bf797e8e69add0"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ViFhCEpr", "prerequisiteId": "ca_H3MjYiKy", "type": "component", "strength": "hard", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他只能拍出单一的拍子，无法在拍子中加入长短变化，导致编创的节奏听起来始终是均匀的，没有重复和变化的对比。", "reason": "「按要求独立或与他人合作表现有重复和变化的」是母条「按要求独立或与他人合作编创、表现有重复和」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "eeee4554194484f4"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ZybYqDTi", "prerequisiteId": "ca_zFPssDTW", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他只能描述舞蹈动作，但说不出这些动作如何体现民族风格或情感表达。", "reason": "「能说出一段舞蹈的审美特征与风格特点」是母条「能说出一段舞蹈或戏剧片段的审美特征与风格」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "7975bb88cd6308d8", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ZybYqDTi", "prerequisiteId": "ca_nFsezrqA", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他只会描述舞蹈片段，遇到戏剧片段时，张口就说'这个舞蹈的旋转动作'，完全没意识到台词和表演才是核心。", "reason": "「能说出一段戏剧片段的审美特征与风格特点」是母条「能说出一段舞蹈或戏剧片段的审美特征与风格」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "ae5097ca16f8ed26", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ZybYqDTi", "prerequisiteId": "ca_uhkRPdSF", "type": "component", "strength": "hard", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他会卡在“并解释其表现内容和内在意蕴”这一步，具体表现为：他能用“优美、激烈、古典”等词说出舞蹈或戏剧片段的风格特点，但一到要解释具体情节和人物情感时，就卡住说“这段舞就是表现了一个故事”，却说不出来是什么故事、人物在做什么、为什么这么做。", "reason": "「能解释一段戏剧片段的表现内容和内在意蕴」是母条「能说出一段舞蹈或戏剧片段的审美特征与风格」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "4fc3818aadddef43"}
{"anchorId": "ca_E7X5tLJn", "prerequisiteId": "ca_fPETeiQk", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他会在输入代码时反复点击图形化工具的拖拽按钮，试图用鼠标把代码块拖进程序窗口，而不是在键盘上敲击输入。", "reason": "「能使用图形化工具设计日常物品与居室环境」是母条「能使用图形化工具和简单的程序语言设计日常」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "e9b937cf74892521"}
{"anchorId": "ca_E7X5tLJn", "prerequisiteId": "ca_nN3MyATF", "type": "component", "strength": "hard", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他只能拖动图形化模块拼出形状，但当需要给模块设定具体尺寸数值时，会直接输入想象中的大小而不进行测量换算，导致拼出的模型比例严重失调。", "reason": "「能使用简单的程序语言设计日常物品与居室环」是母条「能使用图形化工具和简单的程序语言设计日常」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "877040817fe5d2b3"}
{"anchorId": "ca_CAPMuZru", "prerequisiteId": "ca_aaxFZgki", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "能做母条里其余部分，唯独这一段做不出来，错点就落在这里", "reason": "「能根据需要设计海报」是母条「能根据需要设计海报、请柬等」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "25707828e3a34749"}
{"anchorId": "ca_CAPMuZru", "prerequisiteId": "ca_iZ76CL7U", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "能做母条里其余部分，唯独这一段做不出来，错点就落在这里", "reason": "「能根据需要设计请柬」是母条「能根据需要设计海报、请柬等」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "9f7f69fb1f2a2c8f"}
{"anchorId": "ca_EqYJ50K3", "prerequisiteId": "ca_LjfxKLWv", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "将相机拿在手里，快门按不下去，就直接对准物体按手机拍照键，拍完一张就用胶水贴在纸上，而不是连续拍多张同一位置的静态照片", "reason": "「能尝试用数码相机拍摄」是母条「能尝试用数码相机、摄像设备拍摄，制作定格」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "e0dd35fb1a8dab6b"}
{"anchorId": "ca_EqYJ50K3", "prerequisiteId": "ca_qejhLsuT", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "能做母条里其余部分，唯独这一段做不出来，错点就落在这里", "reason": "「能尝试用摄像设备拍摄」是母条「能尝试用数码相机、摄像设备拍摄，制作定格」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "def49a43fa9c01dc"}
{"anchorId": "ca_EqYJ50K3", "prerequisiteId": "ca_SgkzaBtW", "type": "component", "strength": "hard", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他摆好玩偶后，每次移动一点就按一次快门，但拍完后发现照片顺序是反的，玩偶动作倒着播放。", "reason": "「能制作定格动画作品」是母条「能尝试用数码相机、摄像设备拍摄，制作定格」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "681c6fac01b8d541"}
{"anchorId": "ca_GEcXT9GC", "prerequisiteId": "ca_W6HKyPCz", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他在纸上列出的差异点全都是风格、色彩这类表面特征，完全没碰触到创作媒介或传播方式的不同。", "reason": "「能识别数字媒体艺术与传统艺术之间的差异」是母条「能识别数字媒体艺术与传统艺术之间的差异和」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "50efe64742f6398e", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_GEcXT9GC", "prerequisiteId": "ca_hFHPFZaM", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "在讨论数字媒体艺术与传统艺术的差异时，他只能复述课本上关于数字媒体艺术的定义，但无法举例说明两者在创作工具或观看体验上的具体不同，比如无法指出数字绘画可以无限修改而油画颜料干后难以更改。", "reason": "「能识别数字媒体艺术与传统艺术之间的相互作」是母条「能识别数字媒体艺术与传统艺术之间的差异和」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "e8312b7deb4624e2", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_GEcXT9GC", "prerequisiteId": "ca_7deF4pSt", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他在讨论数字媒体优势时，可能会直接列出优点，但当被问及具体弊端时，他只会说'就是不好'，却举不出任何具体的实践案例。", "reason": "「能识别数字媒体在实践运用中的利弊效应」是母条「能识别数字媒体艺术与传统艺术之间的差异和」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "c67ffaaf440618fb"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ZMXn96BD", "prerequisiteId": "ca_QE4CKL3S", "type": "component", "strength": "hard", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他画的图案只是随意拼凑，没有按照对称或重复的规律来排列。", "reason": "「能运用远古艺术的元素创造新的、有个性的艺」是母条「能运用远古艺术的元素、形式法则创造新的、」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "0ee6fb89399ea4a4"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ZMXn96BD", "prerequisiteId": "ca_RpyL9Fqn", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他在调色时把绿色和蓝色直接混合，而不是分层叠加，导致颜色浑浊，无法表现出传统青绿山水的层次感。", "reason": "「能运用远古艺术的形式法则创造新的、有个性」是母条「能运用远古艺术的元素、形式法则创造新的、」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "3456d244f36f357d"}
{"anchorId": "ca_eprdnifs", "prerequisiteId": "ca_yfxKiT48", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他能说出这是龙，但指着龙鳞说这是鱼鳞，指着龙爪说这是鸡爪，无法描述龙特有的表现特征。", "reason": "「能识别不同艺术门类中龙的造型」是母条「能识别不同艺术门类中龙的造型、表现特征」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "d6cd6673fc1d33df", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_RXPwf3WJ", "prerequisiteId": "ca_vmtXjEer", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他能说出建筑用了对称，但评述时只会重复'好看''整齐'，说不出对称如何影响建筑的功能或给人的感受。", "reason": "「能运用对称、比例等形式原理，分析一件建筑」是母条「能运用对称、比例等形式原理，分析并评述一」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "35d27d25f3c8157c", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_RXPwf3WJ", "prerequisiteId": "ca_A6dhSDJA", "type": "component", "strength": "hard", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "学生只说‘这栋楼好看’，但当老师问‘哪里对称’时，指着左右窗户却说不出具体哪一部分对称，或只说‘都一样大’而无法指出具体比例关系。", "reason": "「能运用对称、比例等形式原理，评述一件建筑」是母条「能运用对称、比例等形式原理，分析并评述一」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "109f588e53da9eec"}
{"anchorId": "ca_gShB8Fhi", "prerequisiteId": "ca_j3aZY9i9", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "学生盯着题目，笔悬在纸上，最终只写下'山水'两个字，然后反复涂改，无法写出第二个题材，更无法说明文化寓意。", "reason": "「能举例说出至少两种中国传统绘画的典型题材」是母条「能举例说出至少两种中国传统绘画的典型题材」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "1300061db3a39493", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_SkXX5piw", "prerequisiteId": "ca_jTXkKuP3", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他写'情感'时画了一个哭泣的小人，但被要求加'环境'后，就在哭泣小人旁边乱涂了一团看不出是什么的色块", "reason": "「能举例说明美术如何用于表达个人情感」是母条「能举例说明美术如何用于表达个人情感、描绘」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "532d7438926dd67d"}
{"anchorId": "ca_SkXX5piw", "prerequisiteId": "ca_54GeMubQ", "type": "component", "strength": "hard", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他画人物时只会画火柴人，无法画出具体五官和表情，导致无法通过画面传达情感或描绘他人特征。", "reason": "「能举例说明美术如何用于描绘他人」是母条「能举例说明美术如何用于表达个人情感、描绘」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "ea1dd7db521165c0"}
{"anchorId": "ca_SkXX5piw", "prerequisiteId": "ca_kgT7AJNx", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "学生在画“反映周围环境”时，会反复涂抹画面但说不清表达了什么，只会模仿范画中的房子树木，无法举例解释作品如何反映现实。", "reason": "「能举例说明美术如何用于反映周围环境」是母条「能举例说明美术如何用于表达个人情感、描绘」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "040274292c61a728", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_VN2kREMc", "prerequisiteId": "ca_HBRjZrwk", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "在分析社会责任时，他会说'比如这个海报用红色很醒目'，然后就停住了，无法将色彩与具体社会议题或人群需求关联起来。", "reason": "「能举例说明一个设计作品如何满足形式美感的」是母条「能举例说明一个设计作品如何同时满足形式美」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "48ac0a295cfcb980"}
{"anchorId": "ca_VN2kREMc", "prerequisiteId": "ca_ztGAW7fw", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他举例时只说作品好看，却说不出它具体怎么用，比如指着一把椅子说'它很美'，但讲不出坐上去怎么舒服、怎么省力。", "reason": "「能举例说明一个设计作品如何满足实用功能的」是母条「能举例说明一个设计作品如何同时满足形式美」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "2a4820d512723cf6"}
{"anchorId": "ca_VN2kREMc", "prerequisiteId": "ca_GUJAxpz5", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他会在社会责任部分卡住，比如举出一个设计作品后，只能描述它好看和好用，但说不出它如何帮助了特定人群或解决了社会问题，最后可能硬编一句'它让大家都开心'来凑数。", "reason": "「能举例说明一个设计作品如何满足社会责任的」是母条「能举例说明一个设计作品如何同时满足形式美」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "8fad0cf26e43c5e4", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_Ue3kgnet", "prerequisiteId": "ca_qJhCQUD2", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他能说出声音和肢体方法，但说到情感时卡住，反复说'就是那种感觉'却举不出具体例子，最后低头不说话。", "reason": "「能说出戏剧游戏重点学习的声音表现方法各一」是母条「能说出戏剧游戏重点学习的声音、肢体、情感」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "650f63e6158021e7"}
{"anchorId": "ca_Ue3kgnet", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Ah9CM7hK", "type": "component", "strength": "hard", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "他能说出声音和情感方法，但说到肢体方法时卡住，低头不语或重复之前说过的声音方法。", "reason": "「能说出戏剧游戏重点学习的肢体表现方法各一」是母条「能说出戏剧游戏重点学习的声音、肢体、情感」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "91ebb55fe9f77d6f"}
{"anchorId": "ca_Ue3kgnet", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Ld8fcr8L", "type": "component", "strength": "soft", "inInferenceGraph": true, "failureSignature": "能做母条里其余部分，唯独这一段做不出来，错点就落在这里", "reason": "「能说出戏剧游戏重点学习的情感表现方法各一」是母条「能说出戏剧游戏重点学习的声音、肢体、情感」的一个子动作", "evidence": [{"kind": "set-containment", "detail": "子条文字全部来自母条原句，机器校验（不许新增一个实词）"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "6a71f95d1d49e74f"}
{"anchorId": "ca_JWpX9Hte", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4mBPhXJr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解中国传统绘画技法是历代探索总结而成，就无法理解其典型性并举例。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 32，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他可能说出“勾线”“渲染”等词，但无法解释这些技法如何由历代画家探索总结，或举例时混淆技法与画种（如把“工笔”当技法）", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "85b74cd5aa158f2c", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ztGAW7fw", "prerequisiteId": "ca_o5ghwPHL", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道实用与美观相结合是设计原则，就无法理解实用功能在设计中的体现。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 33，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他会失败在无法举出具体的实用功能例子，或者举出的例子其实是美观方面的，比如指着一个花瓶说'它很漂亮所以实用'", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "3e2508df092f0c63", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ztGAW7fw", "prerequisiteId": "ca_fxdVfb5z", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能举例说明生活用品如何体现实用与美观，就难以迁移到举例说明设计作品满足实用功能。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 39，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他拿起一支笔，只说“它能写字”，却说不出笔杆的弧度如何贴合手型、笔帽的卡扣如何防止丢失等具体设计细节。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "fd556adf0bd5b800", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_fPETeiQk", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6kuQkLDH", "strength": "soft", "reason": "需先理解形状、色彩、空间等造型元素，才能用于物品与环境设计。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 20，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G5 → G6"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他画椅子时只画一个方块当座面，不会加靠背和腿，因为不知道空间关系需要不同形状组合", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "9dcca95f23617fea", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_fPETeiQk", "prerequisiteId": "ca_aflpJ0Do", "strength": "soft", "reason": "需先理解人与自然和谐共生的原则，才能应用于居室环境设计。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 21，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G5 → G6"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "画客厅布局时，只把沙发、茶几、电视摆成一排，全挤在墙边，中间空出大片无用区域，没有考虑人走动的路线和活动需求。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "8ddb21cc5f200d16"}
{"anchorId": "ca_pP52rwAH", "prerequisiteId": "ca_jygTd3sQ", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能区分音乐类别，就无法进一步区分更具体的体裁。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 13，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "ff898e52025ddee1"}
{"anchorId": "ca_pP52rwAH", "prerequisiteId": "ca_gShcURME", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能区分音乐表现形式，就无法准确判断其体裁。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 14，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "老师播放一首二胡曲，他会在表格里把二胡填进西洋乐器栏。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "a737426a422213fd", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_jygTd3sQ", "prerequisiteId": "ca_gShcURME", "strength": "soft", "reason": "区分表现形式是识别音乐类别的关键前提，缺乏此知识则无法完成分类。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 14，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "983164f036dbdd59"}
{"anchorId": "ca_gShcURME", "prerequisiteId": "ca_dyQNHCBB", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析特点，就无法理解表现形式的具体特征和作用。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 15，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "学生只听音色和乐器数量，直接说“有鼓有吉他所以是流行乐”，忽略了速度、节奏型和歌词内容等关键特征。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "e97d55e4e43193fb"}
{"anchorId": "ca_YEXJBaja", "prerequisiteId": "ca_dyQNHCBB", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能运用所学知识分析特点，就无法进一步分析其表现作用。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生会直接跳过分析特点，只罗列画面元素，无法解释这些元素如何共同作用产生特定效果", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "e9076081808f2cf0", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_zFPssDTW", "prerequisiteId": "ca_MQCrMQfj", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能判断和描述音乐作品的风格类型，就无法类比分析舞蹈的审美特征", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 9，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "当老师要求描述舞蹈审美特征时，学生可能只会说“很好看”或“有民族特色”，但无法具体指出是哪个民族、属于哪种风格类型，也说不出其体裁、形式或审美特征的具体表现。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "3944e4a5e48a32d6", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_nFsezrqA", "prerequisiteId": "ca_tYiB4tEC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析音乐在戏剧中的表现作用，就无法说出戏剧片段的审美特征与风格特点", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他无法区分该剧种的板式节奏是快板还是慢板，也说不出唱腔中的拖腔是圆润还是高亢。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "f6b440b7296fd589", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_uhkRPdSF", "prerequisiteId": "ca_tYiB4tEC", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析音乐在戏剧中的表现作用，就无法解释戏剧片段的表现内容和内在意蕴。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "解释戏剧表现内容时，他无法指出音乐如何烘托人物情绪、推动情节发展，只会复述台词和简单描述画面。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "53d9344697a90f41", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_nN3MyATF", "prerequisiteId": "ca_fPETeiQk", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会使用图形化工具就无法结合程序语言进行设计", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 4，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他会在屏幕上反复拖拽图形元素，试图用鼠标画出椅子的形状，而不是输入代码指令，导致程序无法识别他的操作。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "db128947da36058d", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_aaxFZgki", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Rg2mNCdA", "strength": "soft", "reason": "设计海报需要先具备构思和创作美术作品的能力。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 24，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他会在构想阶段卡住，反复擦改草图，无法确定用什么图形和文字来表达主题，最终交白纸或只画一个孤立的图案。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "0546cba1e9ac625b", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_iZ76CL7U", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Rg2mNCdA", "strength": "soft", "reason": "设计请柬需要先掌握构思多种表现形式和方法创作美术作品的能力", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 24，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他会在画边框时反复擦改，试图画出多种不同风格的装饰图案，但最终只画出一条歪歪扭扭的线，无法确定请柬的整体布局。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "4bc8c69896894a17"}
{"anchorId": "ca_SgkzaBtW", "prerequisiteId": "ca_LjfxKLWv", "strength": "soft", "reason": "定格动画需要逐帧拍摄，必须先掌握数码相机的基本拍摄操作。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 7，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他拿起相机后，会反复按快门，但拍出的每张照片都是完全相同的画面，无法形成连续动作。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "0d83315da4e5b69d", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_SgkzaBtW", "prerequisiteId": "ca_qejhLsuT", "strength": "soft", "reason": "定格动画需要逐帧拍摄，必须先掌握摄像设备的基本拍摄操作。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 8，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生拿起摄像机后，直接按住快门不放，像拍普通视频一样持续录制，而不是拍一张、移一点、再拍一张。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "77fb830172325c60"}
{"anchorId": "ca_hFHPFZaM", "prerequisiteId": "ca_W6HKyPCz", "strength": "soft", "reason": "识别相互作用需先识别两者差异，这是比较分析的基础前提。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他会在比较两幅作品时，只列出各自特点，但无法指出它们如何互相影响或融合。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "19347f9afb7d1eb2"}
{"anchorId": "ca_7deF4pSt", "prerequisiteId": "ca_W6HKyPCz", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先识别数字媒体与传统艺术的差异，就无法分析其在实践运用中的利弊效应。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他无法区分数字媒体与传统艺术的差异，因此在分析数字媒体利弊时，会把传统艺术的缺点（如传播慢）误认为是数字媒体的缺点，或把数字媒体的优点（如可复制）误认为是传统艺术的优点。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "37550bba9b851e28", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_7deF4pSt", "prerequisiteId": "ca_hFHPFZaM", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解数字媒体与传统艺术的相互作用，就无法全面评估其实践运用的利弊。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 2，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "举例数字媒体利弊时，他说不出'传统艺术'这个词，只会笼统说'老派艺术不好'或'旧的东西没用'，无法具体对比两者的差异点。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "2fa9a3abfcab9465", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_QE4CKL3S", "prerequisiteId": "ca_RpyL9Fqn", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会运用远古艺术的形式法则，就无法运用其元素进行创造", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 3，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他会在画布上画出一个类似图腾的图案，但只是简单地把三角形、圆形等几何形状拼在一起，没有尝试用这些形状去组合成一个有个性的新形象，比如一个独特的动物或人物。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "79efc91ebdd2e044", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_vmtXjEer", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6kuQkLDH", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先识别造型元素就无法分析建筑的对称与比例形式原理", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 3，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他指着建筑照片说‘这里有个三角形’，但无法说出三角形与旁边矩形的比例关系，只能反复描述‘这个大那个小’，无法比较具体尺寸。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "ea6c6f2e4dde2f21", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_A6dhSDJA", "prerequisiteId": "ca_vmtXjEer", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会分析建筑造型特点，就无法进一步评述其造型特点", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 9，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他在评述时只会说'这个建筑很好看'，但说不出任何具体的对称或比例特点，也找不到画面中对应的线条或结构来支撑自己的观点。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "1d2b40d51aea3236", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_j3aZY9i9", "prerequisiteId": "ca_TIMBScHh", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道中国传统绘画是什么，就无法举出其典型题材。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 6，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他可能说出'山水'和'花鸟'，但无法解释它们为何属于中国传统绘画，或混淆为西方风景画和静物画。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "c1f48b6c84530b0d", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_NbsNMYCr", "prerequisiteId": "ca_TIMBScHh", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道中国传统绘画的文化地位，就无法说明其文化寓意", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 6，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "指着画说'这幅画表达了画家对大自然的热爱'，但说不出'热爱自然'是儒家'天人合一'思想的体现，也说不出'梅兰竹菊'象征君子品格，只能反复说'好看''有意境'。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "ce6fee77aabca43a", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_NbsNMYCr", "prerequisiteId": "ca_j3aZY9i9", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先掌握传统绘画的典型题材，就难以阐释其文化寓意", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 21，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "无法举例说出梅兰竹菊等具体题材，只能空泛地说象征高洁，或把山水画说成象征科技发达", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "6021aa0a024a14f4", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_NbsNMYCr", "prerequisiteId": "ca_JWpX9Hte", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解传统绘画的典型技法，就难以阐释其文化寓意", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 22，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他描述寓意时，只能反复说'这画很有文化'，却无法像同学那样，指着画面解释'用小斧劈皴画的山石体现了文人刚毅的风骨'。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "4b81b1bfe30787c6"}
{"anchorId": "ca_jTXkKuP3", "prerequisiteId": "ca_JNUfKbit", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解美术是认识与表现自我的方式，就无法举例说明其用于表达个人情感。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 7，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他无法将“表达个人情感”与“认识自我”联系起来，只是机械地描述画面内容，比如只说“画了红色的花”，而说不出“用红色表达愤怒”。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "ec5d9f00956bff32", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_jTXkKuP3", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6kuQkLDH", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先掌握造型元素如色彩，就难以分析美术如何表达情感。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 3，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "要求解释色彩如何表达情感时，他只会指认出图片里的红色、蓝色，但无法说出这些颜色让人感到高兴或悲伤，只能说‘因为老师教过红色是热情的’。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "bcdb34ed91d27fbb", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_54GeMubQ", "prerequisiteId": "ca_JNUfKbit", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解美术是认识与表现他人的方式，就无法具体举例说明如何描绘他人。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 7，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生无法将“描绘他人”与“认识自我、他人和周围世界”建立联系，只会机械地画人像，无法解释这幅画如何帮助认识或表现这个人的特点。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "6b213f45e8ad0650", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_54GeMubQ", "prerequisiteId": "ca_jTXkKuP3", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先掌握举例说明美术表达情感的方法，就难以迁移到描绘他人这一具体应用上。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 11，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他画人物时只画五官轮廓，不会用色彩或笔触表现人物的情绪状态，比如画悲伤的人只画下垂的嘴角，但不会用冷色调或颤抖的线条来强化这种情感。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "9d67f8b6228d4f69"}
{"anchorId": "ca_kgT7AJNx", "prerequisiteId": "ca_JNUfKbit", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解美术是认识与表现周围世界的方式，就无法举例说明其如何用于反映环境", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 7，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "面对白纸时，手停在半空不画，只反复说‘我不知道要表现什么’，把‘表现自我’等同于画自画像。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "77bfd1c6ef6b2add", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_HBRjZrwk", "prerequisiteId": "ca_BVd9yLg4", "strength": "soft", "reason": "设计原则是理解形式美感的基础，不掌握原则就无法分析设计作品的形式要求", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他无法将“形式美感”与“功能”“社会责任”区分开，举例时会把“好用”或“环保”也当作形式美感来描述。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "5fb452f92d7337ea", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ztGAW7fw", "prerequisiteId": "ca_BVd9yLg4", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解设计原则包含功能，就无法举例说明设计作品如何满足实用功能要求。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他无法从设计原则的角度切入，只能凭感觉说'这个杯子能装水'，但说不出'为什么这个形状能装水'或'这个设计如何解决了喝水时的其他问题'。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "432c73e622e86473", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_GUJAxpz5", "prerequisiteId": "ca_BVd9yLg4", "strength": "soft", "reason": "设计原则是形式、功能和社会责任相统一，不先理解这一原则就无法举例说明社会责任", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生举的例子是商品美观、价格便宜，只提到形式和功能，始终说不出这和‘社会责任’有什么关系", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "1978000655f7d69f", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_qJhCQUD2", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6tiC4rHQ", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道戏剧游戏重点学习声音表现方法，就无法说出各一种具体方法", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 18，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生可能无法区分声音、肢体、情感三个类别，直接说出一个肢体动作（如跺脚）或情感状态（如开心）作为声音表现方法。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "eed6b7b60bd02d1c", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_Ah9CM7hK", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6tiC4rHQ", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道戏剧游戏重点学习声音、肢体、情感表现方法，就无法说出其中肢体表现方法各一种", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 18，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "64424ed193bc8e48"}
{"anchorId": "ca_Ld8fcr8L", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6tiC4rHQ", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道戏剧游戏重点学习内容包含情感表现方法，就无法说出各一种具体方法。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 18，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他说不出戏剧游戏重点学习的情感表现方法，只会反复说“戏剧游戏很重要”或者沉默摇头。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "22963b3943a1d856", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_MAWDR2Ra", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Rg2mNCdA", "strength": "soft", "reason": "陶艺创作属于美术造型，需先掌握构思多种表现形式创作美术作品的能力", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 21，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "揉泥时没有反复摔打排气，直接开始拉坯，导致坯体内部有大量气泡，在烧制时炸裂。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "ed78b28c6c587e9e", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_MAWDR2Ra", "prerequisiteId": "ca_AmiAFxFQ", "strength": "soft", "reason": "陶艺制作需要持之以恒的创作态度和主动解决问题的能力", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 22，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生会因为泥条盘筑时手劲不匀导致陶罐一侧塌陷，然后直接丢弃泥土去玩，而不是重新揉泥调整。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "e750dce75c4d141e"}
{"anchorId": "ca_i4vVPJMs", "prerequisiteId": "ca_9MTwuMQj", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会听辨音乐要素引起的情感变化，就无法描述音乐的体裁、形式和风格特征。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他会指着乐谱上的音符走向说‘这里情绪在上升’，但说不出是大调转小调导致的；或者仅凭听感说‘这很激动’，却无法识别出快节奏和强力度等具体要素，只能给出模糊的整体印象。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "48aaa0e82009e3c5", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_dyQNHCBB", "prerequisiteId": "ca_SxrKsY92", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能区分体裁、类别和表现形式，就无法运用知识分析其特点和表现作用", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 7，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生无法说出该音乐属于哪种体裁，因此无法针对该体裁的典型特征进行分析，只能泛泛地说“好听”或“有感情”。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "4f147d28747a6aef", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_qejhLsuT", "prerequisiteId": "ca_LjfxKLWv", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会用数码相机拍摄，就无法尝试用摄像设备拍摄", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 7，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "479e0554c5b843ff"}
{"anchorId": "ca_KxUpKk2F", "prerequisiteId": "ca_yfxKiT48", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先识别龙的造型，就无法进一步识别其表现特征", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 5，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他指着玉龙说这是青铜器，指着壁画龙说这是雕塑，把材质和门类搞混了", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "6c879f12c05cb554", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_KxUpKk2F", "prerequisiteId": "ca_eprdnifs", "strength": "soft", "reason": "该能力已包含识别造型和表现特征，是目标能力的直接前置", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他指着龙的鳞片说这是羽毛，指着龙爪说这是鱼鳍，把所有龙的局部特征都认错成其他动物的部位。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "316dd44c20280482", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_tztBYJnj", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Sr5K4mkB", "strength": "soft", "reason": "分析与评价世界美术风格是分析艺术作品品位和意蕴的基础能力", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 14，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "对着一幅古典油画只说颜色真好看，却说不出它表达了什么情感或历史意义。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "29eed94cd9bcf1f1", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_tztBYJnj", "prerequisiteId": "ca_356tWp8p", "strength": "soft", "reason": "运用造型手段表现主题并具有高雅审美情趣，直接关联分析作品的品位", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 19，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他分析作品时只会说'好看'或'不好看'，无法指出具体用了什么造型手段、色彩搭配或构图来体现'高雅'，只能重复'感觉很高雅'这类空话。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "da931ce6719951aa", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_YEtV9Zer", "prerequisiteId": "ca_356tWp8p", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先掌握运用造型手段美化生活的能力，就无法从生活中发现美并装饰环境", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 19，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他拿着彩纸和剪刀，对着空白的墙壁发呆，不知道该剪什么形状，最后只剪了几个歪歪扭扭的圆形贴上去，颜色搭配得很杂乱。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "8fc6d4c6815e546b", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_YEtV9Zer", "prerequisiteId": "ca_TRZAHH2A", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先学会在生活中运用艺术形式借景抒情，就难以将自然与生活之美转化为装饰", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 17，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "当老师要求“借景抒情”时，他只是把窗外的树画在纸上，画完就说“我画了树，所以有感情了”，但画面没有任何构图设计或色彩安排来表达情绪。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "846e8292319129f5", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_iUwuFeTu", "prerequisiteId": "ca_tztBYJnj", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先学会分析作品品位意蕴，就无法形成个人审美判断并表达", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他只能指着画说'好看'或'不好看'，但说不出为什么，也举不出其他作品来比较。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "21ec017772640ef6", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_iUwuFeTu", "prerequisiteId": "ca_9qKembgt", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能表达思想情感，就无法进一步表达审美意趣", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 15，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他拿起画笔，但完全不知道画什么，只是在纸上反复涂抹同一种颜色，边涂边说'这样好看'，却说不出为什么好看，也无法修改，因为不知道自己想要什么效果。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "de3a8e2b9bfdf8fe", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_iUwuFeTu", "prerequisiteId": "ca_sKi9KP5s", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能表达人文情怀，就难以将审美意趣升华为高雅品位", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他画风景时，只会照搬照片里的颜色，不会调整色调来表达自己想要的宁静或热烈的感觉。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "5246daa2607ea42d"}
{"anchorId": "ca_9qKembgt", "prerequisiteId": "ca_sKi9KP5s", "strength": "soft", "reason": "能表达人文情怀、提升审美品位是表达思想情感、拓展艺术感知的核心目标。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "d20e352cbd3d6e18"}
{"anchorId": "ca_sKi9KP5s", "prerequisiteId": "ca_tztBYJnj", "strength": "soft", "reason": "能分析艺术作品的品位和意蕴，是表达人文情怀和提升审美品位的直接基础。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他描述作品时只说'好看'或'不好看'，无法说出具体哪里打动他，比如色彩、线条或故事，导致表达空洞，像在背诵而非分享真实感受。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "518562c17a708af3", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_TRZAHH2A", "prerequisiteId": "ca_9qKembgt", "strength": "soft", "reason": "表达思想情感是借景抒情的核心目标", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "只会照搬诗句写景色，看不出诗人表达的高兴或悲伤心情", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "2862520fe7f31021", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_6dxHus6c", "prerequisiteId": "ca_UsCrPdhf", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先学会选择适当的艺术形式，就无法进行创造性的艺术表现。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 18，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "他拿起画笔后，只是反复涂同一块颜色，不知道如何用线条和形状去表现一个具体的物体。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "9472720a37c76794"}
{"anchorId": "ca_W8Q4Qhaq", "prerequisiteId": "ca_2FJC4B83", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道国歌是学唱歌曲，就无法进入学唱国歌的活动。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 1，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他会在哪里停顿或唱错？比如他可能无法确定歌曲的开头或结尾，或者中间某句旋律和节奏完全乱套。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "0aed5679769bb79f", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_Y5dZuJqc", "prerequisiteId": "ca_wxy93nLa", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道传统工艺是文化瑰宝，就无法理解其价值并举例说明。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 5，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "fc789f966c6d81b8"}
{"anchorId": "ca_MHJvkF8d", "prerequisiteId": "ca_aznbaEsx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解平行透视的近大远小规律，就无法准确描述室内场景中的透视关系", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 4，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "89f78fa437eacdda"}
{"anchorId": "ca_GjY4KkZS", "prerequisiteId": "ca_GcHZA1D2", "strength": "soft", "reason": "直接点明了第四学段学习任务1的具体内容，是说出它的前提。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 19，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生会盯着题目发呆，或者反复翻书找'演出舞台剧目'这几个字，但找不到'具体内容'在哪里，最后可能空着不写或随便抄一句课文里的其他句子。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "7c9ffebca5f7c624", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_EfLnLu9F", "prerequisiteId": "ca_YEtV9Zer", "strength": "soft", "reason": "要理解美术的作用，需先能从自然和生活中发现美的要素，并运用美术手段表达。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 12，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他指着窗外的树说'这很美'，但被问到'美在哪里'时，只能重复'就是很美'，无法说出形状、颜色或光影等具体要素。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "a642692257f23f0c", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_EfLnLu9F", "prerequisiteId": "ca_tztBYJnj", "strength": "soft", "reason": "要与他人交流艺术感知，需先能分析作品的品位和意蕴，形成健康的审美情趣。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 10，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "6d4e950cb66f4c49"}
{"anchorId": "ca_EfLnLu9F", "prerequisiteId": "ca_9qKembgt", "strength": "soft", "reason": "要理解美术的作用并交流感知，需先能表达思想情感，拓展自身的艺术感知能力。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "指着画中的树说：'我觉得这代表希望'，但无法解释为什么这幅画能表现希望，或它与社会生活有什么关系。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "938f545d976e1506", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_UsCrPdhf", "prerequisiteId": "ca_uyahyxAh", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先在中外经典作品比较中感受不同文化风格，就难以选择适当的艺术形式", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 25，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生可能只会模仿单一文化风格的造型，无法在创作中融合或对比不同文化元素，导致作品缺乏跨文化视角的深度表现。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "dee3f87d6c7c47fd"}
{"anchorId": "ca_P75d86DG", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Mrc7LZYx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会演奏简单的锣鼓经或节奏型，就无法在演奏中融入个性化理解和创意。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 3，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G8"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他拿起锣或鼓槌时，完全不知道该敲哪个部位，或者只能模仿旁边同学的动作，完全无法自己创编哪怕一个新节奏型。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "350a85c70fde3f9c", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_kMJGYbpW", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Mrc7LZYx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能演奏节奏型并进行合奏，就无法与他人合作编创节奏或旋律", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 2，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G8"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他无法独立编创，只能反复敲击同一个节奏型，无法加入任何变化。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "3d4e1a094ce82e15", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_TIMBScHh", "prerequisiteId": "ca_wxy93nLa", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解中国传统工艺是文化瑰宝，就无法理解传统绘画的文化地位", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 5，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "179fb1b8cb0c74d4"}
{"anchorId": "ca_j3aZY9i9", "prerequisiteId": "ca_wxy93nLa", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道中国传统工艺是文化瑰宝，就难以建立对传统绘画题材的认知基础", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 5，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他说不出梅兰竹菊或山水人物，只会反复说‘我不知道’或重复老师刚才讲过的例子，无法举出新的题材。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "c624fbd27d0f4b40", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_ztGAW7fw", "prerequisiteId": "ca_e5u7YFZu", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道日常用品是经过设计的，就无法理解设计作品如何满足实用功能", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 6，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他拿起一个杯子，指着杯口说：'这个设计是为了好看'，却说不出杯口大小如何方便喝水。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "53330566acb68ed3", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_gShB8Fhi", "prerequisiteId": "ca_wxy93nLa", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解传统工艺是文化瑰宝，就无法深入理解传统绘画的文化寓意", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 5，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "他可能举出“山水画”和“花鸟画”，但解释寓意时只会说“好看”或“代表大自然”，无法说出“寄情山水”或“象征吉祥”等文化内涵。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "484b65fb1cf5dce3"}
{"anchorId": "ca_gShB8Fhi", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Y5dZuJqc", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先掌握民间传统工艺实例，就难以迁移到对传统绘画题材的举例说明", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 11，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "当被问到‘仕女图’时，他眼神茫然，小声嘀咕‘是不是画那些穿古装的姐姐’，但说不出这是中国画题材，更无法解释其寓意。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "8c49d374ac924cf9", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_nutkmCrm", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Go3P6uox", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道舞蹈学习任务包括小型歌舞剧表演和即兴表演，就无法理解音乐作品可以是舞蹈。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 19，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "5380c751e7c05b43"}
{"anchorId": "ca_X3pI2fSV", "prerequisiteId": "ca_3auPHa3i", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解听赏与评述是音乐学习任务，就无法理解广义音乐作品包含戏剧片段等", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 12，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "让他举出广义音乐作品的例子，他可能会只说出歌曲或器乐曲，漏掉戏剧片段、舞剧等，因为不理解音乐任务的广泛性。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "8d36726ff4dea2b9", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_aflpJ0Do", "prerequisiteId": "ca_e5u7YFZu", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道物品经过设计就无法理解环境设计的原则", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 6，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "b1b267280d550a7c"}
{"anchorId": "ca_6v98UFFD", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Y5dZuJqc", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能举例中国民间传统工艺，就无法举一反三理解世界各国美术作品的文化载体作用", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 11，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "8c49fde84198ce9d"}
{"anchorId": "ca_6tiC4rHQ", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Go3P6uox", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解舞蹈学习任务包含即兴表演，就无法理解戏剧游戏中情感表现的即兴基础", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 19，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "9d1129f2e7aa8ff3"}
{"anchorId": "ca_GcHZA1D2", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Go3P6uox", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道舞蹈学习任务包括小型歌舞剧表演，就无法理解演出舞台剧目是第四学段的任务", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 19，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生会盯着课本目录或单元标题，用手指逐行寻找“第四学段”和“学习任务1”这两个词，找到后直接照着念出“演出舞台剧目”，但无法解释或关联到“小型歌舞剧表演”和“即兴表演”这些具体任务。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "b058ad15bef6a95c", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_j3aZY9i9", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4mBPhXJr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解中国传统绘画技法的形成，就无法理解其典型题材的文化背景", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "ae6e2ea36b6bfe96"}
{"anchorId": "ca_NbsNMYCr", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4mBPhXJr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解中国传统绘画技法的形成，就无法理解其文化寓意的来源", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他会让学生把竹子直接等同于画竹子的技法，比如误以为竹竿的画法就叫“气节”。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "35da86da45888ff1", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_HBRjZrwk", "prerequisiteId": "ca_o5ghwPHL", "strength": "soft", "reason": "需知道设计原则才能说明作品如何满足美感要求", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 17，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他找不到形式美感的例子，只能反复说'这个东西很漂亮'或'这样设计很实用'，无法解释比例、色彩或造型如何产生美感。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "494af599cadb5b2e"}
{"anchorId": "ca_GUJAxpz5", "prerequisiteId": "ca_o5ghwPHL", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解实用与美观相结合的设计原则，就无法分析设计作品如何满足社会责任。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 17，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "2741b9a3b56c683b"}
{"anchorId": "ca_GUJAxpz5", "prerequisiteId": "ca_fxdVfb5z", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能举例说明设计原则的应用，就无法进一步举例说明设计如何满足社会责任。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 23，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生会一直在列举杯子、台灯等物品，只描述“既好看又好用”，无法从社会群体角度举出符合无障碍设计或环保理念的例子，最终交白卷或强行编造一个与社会责任无关的个人喜好描述。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "3242cb0578a9920a", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_2YLUPFTb", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Go3P6uox", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先知道舞蹈学习任务包括小型歌舞剧表演和即兴表演，就无法举例说明音乐作品可以是舞蹈。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 19，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "学生会盯着题目发呆，或反复翻看课本目录，无法将“舞蹈”与“音乐作品”建立联系，最终交白卷或写下无关内容如“唱歌”。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "b8f9156d22495625", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_gShB8Fhi", "prerequisiteId": "ca_4mBPhXJr", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先了解传统绘画技法的发展脉络，就难以准确举例并说明其技法特点", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 16，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生可能无法举例，或举例后无法说明其文化寓意，例如只说出“山水画”但说不出其象征自然与人文和谐的寓意。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "8959d046d4cd38b2", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_VN2kREMc", "prerequisiteId": "ca_fxdVfb5z", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能举例说明生活用品体现实用与美观，就难以迁移到更复杂的设计作品分析。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 23，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "学生会卡在第一步，因为不懂如何举例说明生活用品的美观与实用结合，可能完全无法开始，或举出无关的例子。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "7d64b59c576b489e", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_E1EwtpHn", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Mrc7LZYx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会演奏简单节奏型就无法尝试为自制乐器演奏伴奏或表现", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 13，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G3"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他拿起两个空塑料瓶对敲，但敲出的声音很闷，于是停下来反复调整瓶子里的水量，试图让声音变响亮。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "957b789e0b8fa769"}
{"anchorId": "ca_LLtE7WXj", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Mrc7LZYx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会演奏简单节奏型并伴奏，就无法为歌曲伴奏或表现音乐情境", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 13，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G3"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他拿起两个空瓶子敲击，但节奏完全混乱，无法与歌曲的节拍对齐，只能胡乱敲打。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "d0a354222635d2da", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_Go3P6uox", "prerequisiteId": "ca_Mrc7LZYx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先会演奏锣鼓经并为演唱和游戏伴奏，就无法支撑歌舞剧表演中的节奏配合", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 13，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G1 → G3"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "831b88b875fafc59"}
{"anchorId": "ca_nQXPLl5G", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6v98UFFD", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解美术作品是文化载体，就无法类比理解影视作为历史载体", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 30，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G5 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 instrument"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "instrument", "failureSignature": "学生会卡在解释影视如何记录历史这一步，比如只能复述电影情节，却说不出电影画面、声音、剪辑等具体元素如何承载历史信息，例如只能指出《辛德勒的名单》里有大屠杀场景，但无法解释黑白影像、特定镜头语言如何传递历史的沉重感。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "1901e828053a4106"}
{"anchorId": "ca_vmtXjEer", "prerequisiteId": "ca_aznbaEsx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解近大远小的透视规律，就无法分析建筑的空间造型特点", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 15，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他指着建筑照片说'这里近大远小'，却无法指出左右对称的窗户或屋顶的比例关系", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "6538c91d151a9dd8", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_A6dhSDJA", "prerequisiteId": "ca_aznbaEsx", "strength": "soft", "reason": "理解近大远小的透视规律是评述建筑空间造型的基础。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 15，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "评述时只谈建筑颜色好不好看，完全不提建筑左右是否对称或窗户的大小比例。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "cfec843e087e11ff", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_A6dhSDJA", "prerequisiteId": "ca_MHJvkF8d", "strength": "soft", "reason": "能用草图或语言描述透视关系是分析建筑空间特点的能力基础。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 22，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他只能指认建筑上有对称和屋顶，但无法说清这些元素如何通过透视让建筑显得高大。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "9349e6a1bf8422eb"}
{"anchorId": "ca_NbsNMYCr", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6v98UFFD", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解美术作品是文化载体，就难以说明绘画的文化寓意", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 30，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G5 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他会把中国山水画简单地说成是'画风景'，而不是'寄情山水'的文化表达，无法说出'天人合一'的寓意。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "048bc8831ee0a200", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_NbsNMYCr", "prerequisiteId": "ca_T8vBLFSD", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先能举例说明不同国家美术作品的文化特征，就难以聚焦说明中国绘画的文化寓意", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 39，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G5 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他无法将中国画的笔墨、留白等视觉特征与“天人合一”“意境”等文化概念联系起来，只能复述课本上的结论，或用西方绘画的构图、色彩标准来分析，导致解释牵强附会。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "6619324840243573", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_HBRjZrwk", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6kuQkLDH", "strength": "soft", "reason": "需要理解造型元素才能分析设计作品的形式美感", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 27，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G5 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他指着作品说'这里用了红色和蓝色'，但说不出'色彩'这个词，也说不出'对比'或'和谐'，只能描述'好看'或'不好看'。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "9a085a3bb6463972", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_HBRjZrwk", "prerequisiteId": "ca_vmtXjEer", "strength": "soft", "reason": "需掌握形式原理才能分析设计作品的造型特点", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 33，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G5 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 convention"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "convention", "failureSignature": "无可观测影响", "inInferenceGraph": false, "retagHash": "30ae31dc3798ee11"}
{"anchorId": "ca_RXPwf3WJ", "prerequisiteId": "ca_o5ghwPHL", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不理解设计原则就无法评述建筑的实用与美观", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 17，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G3 → G5"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 semantic"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "semantic", "failureSignature": "他指着建筑照片说'这个设计很实用'，但说不出'对称'或'比例'这些词，只能描述'左边和右边差不多'，无法分析造型特点。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "f3189fb05d266d1d", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_VN2kREMc", "prerequisiteId": "ca_aflpJ0Do", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先理解人与自然和谐共生的环境设计原则，就无法分析设计作品如何满足社会责任要求。", "crossDiscipline": null, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "候选池 40 选 28，模型提议未复核；本轮已两段式重标"}, {"kind": "standard-hierarchy", "detail": "课标学段序：G5 → G7"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "两段式重标：先写失败表现（不告知有分类任务），再独立调用分类为 component"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "在举例说明社会责任时，学生会卡住，停笔反复写“与自然和谐”但无法展开具体设计做法，最后只能抄写题目要求作为答案。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "retagHash": "e1b7e4bcbe9fa79a", "strengthCappedBy": "matrix-track"}
{"anchorId": "ca_gezPWryU", "prerequisiteId": "ca_6dxHus6c", "strength": "soft", "reason": "不先掌握艺术技能技法，就无法运用多媒体设备进行艺术创作的具体操作。", "type": "component", "failureSignature": "他可能只会用鼠标画出简单线条，无法调整笔刷粗细、透明度，或不会使用图层功能，导致画面混乱无法修改。", "inInferenceGraph": true, "evidence": [{"kind": "llm", "detail": "孤立锚点补边：相关度候选池 40 选 1，三段式未复核"}, {"kind": "llm", "detail": "失败表征由独立调用产出（不告知分类任务），分类为第三次独立调用"}], "reviewStatus": "llm-proposed", "reviewedBy": [], "crossDiscipline": null, "note": "孤立锚点补边（tools/out/edges-isolated.jsonl），入库前须人工复核", "schemaVersion": "0.1.0", "retagHash": "c0771369bb53ae8c"}